Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Madame Déficit

What sparked the French revolution? Hunger, malnutrition, the Ancien Régime, heavy taxes on commoners, powers of the Courts of France and so on. There have been many social, political and economic reasons to answer this question. And why not? One or two odd reasons would not have flared up such an upheaval of the masses. 

In the mix of all these reasons, the one that intrigued me most was - Marie Antoinette. She was an Austrian princess who married Louis XVI. She was not popular among the people of France and she is said to have drained the finances of the country to fulfill her lavish and luxurious lifestyle. She was named Madame Déficit because people saw her as one of the major reasons which led to the nation's bankruptcy.

What amazes me is to imagine how one woman could have impoverished an entire country? Many people claim that all the allegations on the queen were baseless and she just became a scapegoat in the face of the revolution.    

There are also claims that she was one intelligent woman and she would make the difficult decisions for her husband, who on the other hand was supposed to be a lazy and inexperienced king. However, this same trait has been described by some scholars in exactly the opposite sense, where they say that the king was nothing but a stooge and the main player and consequently the cause of the nation's downfall was the queen, all along. 

I started off saying that one reason is not enough to spark a revolution. In that case my question is, how can one justify or argue on the Queen's role to cause about this mass rebel?

4 comments:

  1. Just adding a bit to the tale:
    The French treasury was already under a huge burden due to the heavy losses the French incurred int the Seven Years' War and its other battles with the British in North America. While Marie Antoinette was a documented big-spender, and hasnt been accounted to have a big heart for the people ('If they don't have bread, let them eat cake'), it's kinda absurd to attribute one woman's habits as the cause behind the French Revolution.
    There are many factors responsible for her infamy as the reason behind the fall of Louis XVI. First, she was an Austrian princess, thus born to one of France's biggest enemies, and her motherland was a major gainer from the French ruler's downfall. Also, she failed to attend the Council of Notables meet, which was held after 160 years to address the financial situation, leading people to believe that she did not want the situation to be addressed.
    But during the late 1770s and the 1780s (just prior to the revolution) she played a very active role in French politics. So the conspiracy theorist had a strong point...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you for the additions. My next few articles will be covering the other aspects of the French revolution. As far as this article goes, there's one thing i want to add. It is argued that Marie Antoinette never made the comment - Let them eat cake. This phrase had originally occurred in Rousseau's works where he associated the phrase with an anonymous princess. It is said that there is a possibility that Rousseau may have coined the phrase.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Why do I find similarities with India? An Inexperienced King who is nothing but a stooge handing over the entire Control to a Lady who is from some foreign Country and taking the Nation more and more towards an Economic Catastrophe, is there a Revolution in the offing?

    Anyway, its a good initiative, very Informative indeed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In India the King never had any control in the first place...

      Delete